Skip to main content

This post may contain affiliate links which may compensate us based on your interaction. Please read the disclosures for more information.

Depending on where you live, it’s possible to save a chunk of cash by building instead of buying an existing home.  

Image source: Getty Images

Potential home buyers will be interested to know that it’s now cheaper to build a home in 18 states than it is to buy an existing one. An analysis conducted by StorageCafe, an online platform providing storage unit listings across the country, found that building from scratch can pay off in some parts of the country.

Details of the analysis

Before diving in, it’s important to note how StorageCafe came up with its numbers.Building costs were calculated as being the price of land, plus the median cost of a contract with builders. Another 10% was added in for additional costs, like permits, surveys, and fees for attorneys and real estate agents.Land costs are based on prices as of October 2022.Median contract prices for building are based on 2021 data, then adjusted for inflation at a rate of 8%.Existing home prices are based on October 2022 listings.The study included 46 states, as there was not sufficient data available for Alaska, North Dakota, Rhode Island, or Vermont. Washington D.C. and Puerto Rico were not considered.

Findings

The analysis found that building makes the most sense in areas of the country where home prices remain red hot. How much a buyer can save varies by state.

State Total Building Costs (Land, Construction, and Other Costs) Median Single Family Home Listings Price Difference Between Building vs. Buying Costs Hawaii $551,000 $1,045,000 $494,000 California $495,000 $700,000 $205,000 Colorado $492,000 $600,000 $108,000 Utah $538,000 $635,000 $97,000 Virginia $361,000 $458,000 $96,000 Delaware $394,000 $490,000 $96,000 Maryland $365,000 $460,000 $95,000 Montana $515,000 $599,000 $84,000 Florida $375,000 $451,000 $76,000 Idaho $505,000 $575,000 $70,000 Washington $493,000 $559,000 $66,000 Massachusetts $587,000 $629,000 $53,000 Texas $361,000 $412,000 $51,000 Oregon $502,000 $545,000 $43,000 North Carolina $363,000 $395,000 $32,000 Georgia $365,000 $395,000 $30,000 Tennessee $361,000 $374,000 $13,000 New York $524,000 $535,000 $11,000
Data source: StorageCafe

Reality

The StorageCafe findings are an excellent reminder for buyers. It’s always a good idea to check current prices on both new and existing homes in an area. Of course, that’s only if they can afford to wait for a new home to be built. On average, it takes nearly eight months to build a home from permits to completion.

There’s also the issue of supply and demand. If home builders are inundated with jobs, prices may not drop low enough to justify building. On the other hand, if home builders are hungry for new work, the price point could make an eight-month wait worth the effort.

Where buying an existing home is still the cheapest option

Here’s a sample of states in which home buyers are still better off taking out a mortgage for an existing home.

State Total Building Costs (Land, Construction, and Other Costs) Median Single Family Home Listings Price Difference Between Building vs. Buying Costs Pennsylvania $528,000 $345,000 $183,000 Ohio $450,000 $272,000 $178,000 Illinois $461,000 $295,000 $166,000 Maine $544,000 $380,000 $164,000 Iowa $460,000 $299,000 $161,000 Missouri $445,000 $290,000 $155,000 Michigan $452,000 $299,000 $153,000 South Dakota $479,000 $335,000 $144,000 Indiana $452,000 $310,000 $142,000 West Virginia $358,000 $225,000 $133,000
Data source: StorageCafe

Remember, these are state averages and may not be representative of more or less expensive corners of the state.

Buying a home is a huge commitment. Once you’ve found a mortgage lender you like and know how much you plan to spend, take your time and figure out whether you’re better off buying a home that’s brand new or older.

Our picks for the best credit cards

Our experts vetted the most popular offers to land on the select picks that are worthy of a spot in your wallet. These best-in-class cards pack in rich perks, such as big sign-up bonuses, long 0% intro APR offers, and robust rewards. Get started today with our recommended credit cards.

We’re firm believers in the Golden Rule, which is why editorial opinions are ours alone and have not been previously reviewed, approved, or endorsed by included advertisers.
The Ascent does not cover all offers on the market. Editorial content from The Ascent is separate from The Motley Fool editorial content and is created by a different analyst team.The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.

 Read More 

Leave a Reply